The Sensex Fool’s Four stocks

This is a sequel to last Thursday’s post: Fool’s Four stock investment strategy. Before proceeding further, let me thank readers Googol, Purnendu and Rishi for providing me with their lists.

There are a few stocks common in their lists with mine, but there are differences due to changes in current market prices, adjustments for split/bonus and calculation of dividends. I have checked the list to the extent possible, without turning it into a research project. But there may be errors in my list as well.

The point to note is that the stocks that make the list – with one notable exception – have under-performed the Sensex by various degrees. That is the whole idea behind the Fool’s Four strategy. Without further ado, here are the Sensex Fool’s Four stocks:

1. NTPC
2. Jaiprakash Associates
3. ITC
4. ONGC
5. Wipro
6. Tata Steel

Why 6 stocks? Well, if you read the previous post, you will know that the stock ranked 1 – viz. NTPC - is supposed to be dropped from the list. That leaves 5 stocks. Regular readers may be aware that I am biased against PSU stocks because the government treats them as ‘free ATMs’ and run them to the ground. That eliminates ONGC from my list.

Given below are the one year closing charts of the remaining four – compared with the Sensex (in green):-

Jaiprakash Associates

Jaiprakash Associates has been a significant underperformer for the past one year, and it isn’t a surprise that it is at the top of the list. The company’s ambitions have far exceeded its execution capabilities. The huge debt burden is a millstone around its neck. Since it has fallen so much, the chances are better for a higher percentage gain when the market eventually turns around.

ITC

ITC is the odd-one-out of this list. It was a market performer till Feb ‘11, but has significantly outperformed the Sensex from Mar ‘11 onwards. The special centenary dividend boosted the dividend yield. The dividend is unlikely to be repeated next year. But this is a great stock to own – even if it wasn’t on the list.

Wipro

Wipro had outperformed the Sensex till mid-Jul ‘11. It is the last two months that haven’t gone well. There are management issues that haven’t yet been sorted out to the market’s satisfaction. Of late, it has fallen behind aggressive competitors like Cognizant and HCL Tech. But it is a good company and may fight back.

Tata Steel

Like Wipro, Tata Steel has underperformed the Sensex in the last two months. It is the lowest cost integrated steel maker in India and extremely well-managed. The Corus integration is still a work-in-progress, and the real benefits of the acquisition may be a couple of years away. But I have no doubts that the current problems in Europe will be overcome, and the company’s bottom line will significantly improve.

The Fool’s Four strategy suggests that you invest equal amounts of money in all four stocks, and make any adjustments only after one year. Will the strategy work? There is only one way to find out – by investing. Or, you can opt out by only investing ‘on paper’ and check back after one year.

Fool’s Four stock investment strategy

Let me first assure readers that the Fool’s Four (or Foolish Four) stock investment strategy is neither foolish, nor is it meant to make fools out of investors. It is a ‘mechanical’ investment strategy that can be useful for those investors who haven’t yet developed their stock-picking skills, and have probably lost money chasing ‘cheap’ small-cap stocks.

The Fool’s Four strategy was designed by The Motley Fool investment group as a refinement to the Dogs of the Dow strategy. I had written about the Dogs of the Dow strategy in a post back in Apr ‘10. The strategy works just as well with Sensex stocks. (If you are a recent visitor to this blog, or have forgotten what I wrote more than a year back, you may want to read the earlier post first.) 

Since it is a variation of the Dogs of the Dow strategy, the Fool’s Four involves selection of four stocks from the Dow index (or Sensex) based on low price and high dividend yield. The dividend yield is calculated by dividing the actual dividend per share in Rupees (not the percentage dividends usually announced) by the current market price (CMP) of the share in Rupees.

The selection process involves calculating the square roots of the CMPs, and the dividend yields of each of the 30 Sensex (or Dow) stocks. Next, divide the dividend yield by the square root of the CMP to find a ratio for each stock. Then rank the 30 stocks based on a descending order of ratios (i.e. the stock with the highest ratio will have a rank of 1, and the stock with the lowest ratio will have a rank of 30).

If calculating the square roots of the CMPs is too much of a challenge, you can calculate the square of the dividend yield (multiply the dividend yield by itself) and divide it by the CMP. The ratios will be different, but the rankings will be the same.

Now comes the interesting part. Drop the stock with the rank of 1, and choose the next 4 (ranked 2 through 5). Buy equal Rupee (or Dollar) amounts of each of the short-listed four stocks, and hold them for a year. Why drop the stock with the number 1 rank? There is a good possibility that it may be in financial difficulties. Sensex (or Dow) stocks are supposed to be financially stable, but the odd JP Associates do get in trouble by being over-ambitious.

Is there any logic behind the Fool’s Four strategy, or is it just some foolish number crunching? Apparently, academic studies have proven that (a) high dividend yield leads to better market performance (which is the logic behind the Dogs of the Dow theory); and (b) stock price variations (or ‘beta’) is correlated with the square root of the price.

So, the Fool’s Four strategy gives slightly better results than the Dogs of the Dow (or Sensex) strategy. That doesn’t mean that all four stocks will beat the Sensex. The underperformer(s) should be replaced by stocks from the short-list of four selected next year. The Sensex-beaters can be retained.

(Note: Interested readers can do the exercise of selecting the four stocks from the Sensex that meets the above selection criteria. I’ll post their brief technical analysis once I receive your feedback. Then we can check back after one year and see how well the strategy works.)